8 in 1 Metal Thumbsticks Joysticks Replacement, Swap Magnetic Analogue Stick Grips Buttons Parts with Repair Kit Accessories Compatible with Xbox one Elite Series 1/ PS4(Blue)

I love the options with the Xbox One Elite Controllers where I can swap them out with different colors. Very happy with this set and the Case they provided.

Looks like a great offer, right? You're right. Though there are things that need to be addressed here.We'll start off and go through four categories, and by the end I'll hopefully help you establish if they're right for you.Before we do we need to address the lies of CometSouth.CometSouth in the past had made claims that their kits are OEM parts, which is false!CometSouth at one point made another claim that they source and use materials used for the Xbox Elite V1, which is also false.These claims haven't since been brought up, but they're something everyone should be aware of.Now onto the review.________Quality:This kit has decent quality to it, especially if you're looking for replacement sets on the cheap, they're gonna suffice. All metals are equal to the originals, but are not the same equivalent.There have been some claims that some metal used here has the ability to chip, I've never seen this myself, though it's something to be made aware of.________Consistency:This is where the issue is.Materials used are perfectly fine, though in the listings photo you see the low light media blasted version of the "discs" as people are calling them, but more properly, the analog mounts.When you order these, you run a chance of getting the mirrored finish stainless steel or the media blasted finish, but in my first order of these I received the mirrored finish.This isn't a bad thing, but they need to make people aware of the different finishes.________Materials:My biggest issue all together.While the rubberized pieces used here aren't the same on every piece, and my assumption is they did this to be able to provide an equal number of the same pieces for people who prefer a certain stick type.Some pieces, mainly the dome and smaller concave pieces, use a different type of rubber material.Domes are nearly too smooth and allow for your thumbs to easily slip.Concave feel fine, though the material used allows for a little more thumb area.I just wish this was duly noted as well.________ Fitment:This category has to do with the constant complaints that people are making about the replacements.They're basically the same exact size or nearing. People complains about the mounts being smaller or too loose.This is false! They are going to feel loose if you put them in a normal Xbox One/Xbox Series shell.Get a custom faceplate, something that has decorative rings as it adds the needed support for these sticks.All together these aren't bad.Though there's a huge lack of transparency that makes them hard to know what you're going to get.I'd recommend them, but know that they simply aren't the same exact model, they are a substitute replacement and will work for what they are.

Im not sure why the discs got a semi poor review early up. Their great. The attachments do not fall off and very stable on my ProA Fusion. I like the quick swap and they are very bouncy. When you flick the stick you can feel the spring bounce. They actually seem lighter and smoother than the sticks that came with. Metal/Aluminum is far better than plastic.

Works great! Simple to install on in my Xbox one controller. Movement is nice and smooth grips are comfortable and look great. I’ve tried several thumb stick extenders to improve precision and they all pop off to frequently, not an issue at all with these. Magnet holds thumb stick securely in place.

These are great. They are heavy though. Ye' be warned.

Nice

Bueno

I have been using and installing this brand on alot of Xbox and PS4 controllers but I really took the time with my personal shock blue Xbox X controller to highlight the true blue of it all. Looks even better with the blue cups ( sold separately). That a bummer but I think with the look it has now it was all worth the extra $$.