Vapour Organic Beauty Mesmerize Eyeliner, Ink-Black Velvet, 0.028 Ounce

Switched to this cleaner line from Clinique and won't turn back. NO irritation for my eyes. Lovely color for my hazel green eyes too. Recommend!

I liked this eyeliner but its hard to sharpen and often times chunks will break off after sharpening and get in your eye. I would prefer this eyeliner in a twist up style instead. I won't buy this again because of the hassle with sharpening. It was nice and black and stayed on along time and that was great. I also love the ingredients in this product which is why I purchased in the first place.

This is the worst eyeliner I have ever purchased. It barely goes on and after a few uses of trying to make a line, I sharpened it and it chewed up the whole thing, plus there were hollow openings in the pencil. So expensive, what a waste of money.

Like many customers, I bought this at the recommendation of Kimberly Snyder. I guess I expected something really terrific, but what I got was just a regular ol' eyeliner pencil with smudger. There was absolutely nothing special about this pencil, and I sort of half way wondered if Ms. Snyder gets compensated in some way for her recommendations because huge numbers of people buy the products she recommends. Here are my thoughts about this particular product:The good stuff:1. I love that it's organic2. I like the smudger, the size, the color (black)--although all those things can be said about a $7 pencil bought at the drugstore, so it's really just the fact that it's organic and purportedly healthier that makes it worth the extra $13.3. It doesn't smear like some of the really soft pencils do.The not so good stuff:1. It's expensive. $20 for an eyeliner pencil that must be sharpened every couple of days (while you watch the product whittle away into the trash can) is hard.2. It's not that easy to apply. It didn't go on very easily or evenly, and you absolutely have to use the smudger to make it look natural, especially when it's new and sharp.My favorite organic "healthy" eyeliner is from the Jane Iredale line. It's the same price and I probably like their product better because it goes on smoother and lasts a tad longer, but their product doesn't have a smudger--so maybe it's a wash.

Really good eyeliner, organic, easy to apply, and it stays.

Pros: Love this product. Gives great relief to know that it is organic. Very satisfied with the purchase. will never go back to any other eyeliner ever.Cons : Needs sharpening quite often. so i am almost at the end of finishing this product.will definitely but it again and again. Happy i found this product.

The box was "smushed" and the product was broken in two. Never got to use it. Had to return it! Very disppointing!

Product smudges and won't stay on long.