DollyWink Super Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Super Black

Honestly, I absolutely LOVE DollyWink Liquid Eyeliners and have been using them for years! The only reason I took off a star is because I don't see the difference between this one and the other super black one. Waterproof? The staying power in the original one was long lasting already, so I thought this one would be even more durable. Nope. Same lasting power. Same super black color. Same super fine application. Don't get me wrong, DollyWink is literally my favorite eyeliner. But this is EXACTLY the same as the non-waterproof one, which is actually cheaper. I basically bought the same eyeliner for a higher price and different color packaging.

The media could not be loaded.  This eyeliner is dark with a fine brush tip. The pen is pretty skinny, but I'm hoping that the product will last a while to warrant the price. There's a little bit of bleed, but hand skin texture is very different from eyelid texture since I don't have any fine lines...yet... so I'm fine with it. When I tested it, I was a little concerned that the eyeliner dried kind of shiny, but that can be mattified with powder. The liner is also VERY water proof, but it will come off with micellar water and a lot of **gentle** (no fine lines here, tyvm) rubbing.

I love this eyeliner and have you used it for years. The product seems different, however — I’ve never had problems with smudging and now it’s all over my eyelids. I’m so disappointed.

I usually get the original Dolly Wink eyeliner in the pink (Koji, deep black) but lately Amazon have been sending me old or dried out ones.Decided to try another Dolly Wink liner and so far this eyeliner is great!! It honestly feels like the original pink one but isn’t dried out and very pigmented!I shall update in a few weeks though.

Stays on with primer even after you cry then go to sleep and wake up! Every once in a while it comes out light so you need two coats but other than that, happy with it!

I first purchased this eyeliner back in January and it was perfect, the durability and intensity of the black was exactly what I wanted. I had no issues up until replacement time, and it lasted all day through 95+ degree weather at the Rennisance Festival. A repurchase was a no brainer. The eyeliner arrived on time, packaging was in tact, and it appeared to be the same eyeliner. I have been using it for a month now and started to have issues on week 3. The pen continuiously does not want to dispense eyeliner. It'll give me a watery black line most of the time, then I have to swipe it on the back of my hand a few times to get more liner after shaking it, and it goes back to watery black within a few swipes. I've tried everything, using the side of the marker, shaking it longer, leaving it upside down at all times. And none of this works. It used to take me 5 minutes to do my eyeliner, it now takes me closer to 20. And I don't know if I'll repurchase.

I'm not usually a fan of shiny liners, but this one is just fine with me. It doesnt run, or smudge, and stays crisp all day. Normal eyeliners mess with my left eyelid for whatever reason, making it sticky feeling and leaving itself behind on the lid. This doesnt do that, which is by FAR my favorite thing about it! Now if only it were matte!

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have used Stila and Kat Von D in the past, as well as the pink version of the DollyWink eyeliner. This one blow them all out of the water. The brush is thin and easy to use, and the colour is very pigmented and flows evenly from the pen.