Schmidt's Aluminum-Free Vegan Deodorant Charcoal & Magnesium with 48 Hour Odor Protection, 2 Count for Women and Men, Natural Ingredients, Cruelty-Free, 2.65 oz, Pack of 2

This is going to sound like a damned shill, but I almost NEVER write product reviews because they are usually not worth the time. I'm writing this one because this deodrant shcoked me.I've been using Degree "heat activated" white stick type deodrant since the 1990s. Right through my military service, fatherhood, and now in to my current middle age grey-beard era. While it worked, I started to notice it was getting weaker over the last few years.. heavy focus on fragrance with almost no sweat or real deodorizing capabilities. My wife had tried a bunch of the safer deodorants (no heavy metals, etc) but they didn't work for squat.Annoyed, I bought 2 sticks of this stuff about a week and a half ago for my son and I to try. I was drawn to it being a safer deodorant, but was leery about it working or keeping me dry. Its now day 4 or 5 wearing this stuff (I apply it at night right after I get out of the shower) and it STAYS ACTIVE ALL DANG DAY. No sweat, no overpowering crappy fragrance like the Degree stuff I was trying to get away from.Pros: It works. Packaging looks like something my grandma would buy, but it keeps you dry and odor free for a long time. It says it works for 2 days, but I shower daily and I'm not planning to stretch it out.Cons: Kinda pricey. It works really well and it's not made with aluminum, but geez it's expensive. If they can work on the cost a bit, I'll switch over my entire family (its a big family).

This is the best natural deodorant I’ve used. It keeps me fresh all day, even at the gym! The scent is clean and not too strong. I love that it’s vegan, cruelty-free, and doesn’t leave any white marks. Plus, you get two — great deal!

I’ve been using this charcoal deodorant for a few weeks now, and overall, I’m really happy with it. The scent is fresh without being overpowering—kind of a clean, subtle charcoal smell that’s actually pleasant.It’s effective at keeping odor at bay throughout the day, even during workouts, which is a big plus. I was worried about it burning or irritating my skin since charcoal products sometimes can, but it’s been gentle with no redness or discomfort.The quality feels solid—the texture is smooth and goes on easily without any stickiness or residue. It dries fairly quickly, so I don’t feel like I’m leaving anything sticky behind.If you’re looking for a natural-feeling deodorant that works and smells good, this one’s worth trying.

I switched from Bravo Sierra as, after about a year, it no longer was effective for me. After seeing all the glowing reviews for this I had to try it. Overall it does seem to get the job done - it is effective at eliminating body odor - but with two cons:1) To me the scent isn’t super subtle. In fact, I don’t find the fragrance to be appealing but it’s not super off-putting. For the first 3-5 hours I can still randomly smell it on myself. I don’t really know how to describe the smell except to say it’s not my favorite and if there were other scent options I wouldn’t choose this one.2) It gets on your clothes. I put on my deodorant after showering and about 5 minutes later get dressed. Nearly every time it leaves streaks on the outside of my t shirt and I have to sit there trying to get it off. This may ultimately prove to be a deal-breaker for me as I don’t want to waste time cleaning my shirt every morning. In fact, having just had to clean my shirt is what prompted this review. Maybe if you don’t wear t shirts it won’t be a problem but just beware that this is a common issue, at least in my experience.

I was using a much higher priced charcoal brand but wanted a more affordable option, not to mention it was harder to put on & stained clothes. I am allergic to so many brands, except one, but that one was not lasting all day. So I gave this a try and love it. Lasts all day and night, goes on smoothly, doesn’t stain clothes and has a nice subtle scent.

Out of all the natural deodorants I’ve tried this is the only one that works well. I do have to moisturize more often because of the baking soda but I’m really happy it’s natural and effective. The scent is nice and it keeps me fresh without any harsh ingredients.

After trying countless deodorants, this one stands out for actually doing what it promises. It provides reliable odor protection all day, from work to the gym, without suffocating my skin or clogging pores. Unlike many others that leave a residue or feel sticky, this deodorant feels breathable and clean. It has a very subtle, almost unnoticeable scent, which I appreciate. It keeps me dry and odor-free without irritation. This is now my daily staple and the only brand I trust with my underarm care. I also like that this does not have any harsh chemicals or feel sticky. The fact that it lasts for 48 hours needs to be examined, but I can go a whole day without feeling any odor speaks for the quality.

They keep changing the formula and labeling. Maybe it’s the seller and/or sizing.. I don’t know if the difference is between the 2.65oz or the 3.2 oz 🤷🏾‍♂️. I’ve used this product for years since switching to aluminum free products. Degree Extreme Blast was my go-to but they’ve changed their labeling/packaging and are also on the aluminum side. Granted I’ve aged so body chemistry may have as well. But long story short, this deodorant was amazing at the 3.2oz size. Longevity, scent, etc.. but I wasn’t gonna pay $30+ for 2 sticks for the sake of aluminum free. Since I’ve been rockin with the 2.65oz it’s NOT the same.. longevity wise is NOT it. I used to be able to wear it a whole day, now by the end of the day the semi-good smell (not amazing as it once was) is gone. It turns into a strange smell first then bad, not funky town bad but I can’t describe it bad. Just means it’s shower and reapply time. Yes it leaves marks on your clothes and no it’s not what the majority of reviews say, they’re saying how it used to be imo. Idk.. I’m looking for other options atp .. end of an era 😞