Lon Chaney: Before the Thousand Faces

CHANEY BEFORE THE THOUSAND FACES, A Review, by Fred Long. This DVD, an Undercrank Productions, 82 minutes, offers a rare look at an emerging talent that in a span of just three short years would share the spotlight with the immortals—Douglas Fairbanks, William S. Hart and Tom Mix, Valentino, Chaplin and Keaton—silent stars of the silver screen. Lon Chaney was not the star in any of the three features presented, but his artistry shines in each of them, most notably in THE PLACE BEYOND THE WIND (1916). Just seeing this movie, and the excellent score, expertly synchronized to the action by Jno C. Mirsalis, is well worth the purchase price. I have purchased DVDs in the past where the score is so irritating and repetitious that I have to turn it off. Not so with this DVD, nor with the other two features that make up this outstanding package: A MOTHER’S ATONEMENT (1915) and IF MY COUNTRY SHOULD CALL (1916).Of the three, THE PLACE BEYOND THE WIND is the one that touched this poor soft heart of mine. I actually had watery eyes toward the end of the movie while watching this melodramatic tragedy unfold. Chaney is superb as the half-breed in a screenplay written by Ida May Park and based on the novel by Harriet T. Comstock. Joseph de Grasse, Park’s husband, directed and also played an important part in the film. But it’s Chaney that shines in his attempt to seduce the young innocent Priscilla Glenn (played by Dorothy Phillips) by luring her to an isolated cabin. I don’t want to give away the story, but this is a good one. Unfortunately, as it is with most of the early silent films, some of it is missing and some of it shows the deterioration of time and gross abuse. This one, and IF MY COUNTRY SHOULD CALL, were found in 1978 buried in a landfill in Dawson City, Yukon, Canada. Reel one and reel five is missing, but Mirsalis fills in the gaps with a narrative that keeps the storyline intact, and the damaged sections, for the most part, are not that intrusive. Actually, I was very impressed with the expert handling of this 102-year-old film.IF MY COUNTRY SHOULD CALL is another melodrama written by Ida May Park and directed by Joseph de Grasse. Chaney’s performance is as different from the above film as night is to day. He is somber, serious, as he plays his character, a doctor summoned to the home of a middle-class family where the son is contemplating enlistment in the Army. It is an interesting propaganda film, coming at a time when the nation was feverish with debate over the issue of whether the U.S. should join the war in Europe. The photography, executed by King Gray, is good but not nearly as good as his work in the above film. It’s a good print for the most part, excellent when you consider that it came out of a landfill. The print does have a few problems, but not enough to obscure viewing, and again, Mirsalis does an excellent job in filling in the gaps and gives us a music score that keeps the tension alive, in spite of a rather disappointing story.The final film, the first in this package, is from 1915—A MOTHER’S ATONEMENT. Chaney gives us a glimpse of things to come. He plays the part of a bitter, angry, old man, and except for the trained eye, is unrecognizable in makeup. He tells us, in flashback, where we see him in his younger days, out of makeup, shooting his wife with a rifle for running off with another man. And the plot thickens. This one is another from Ida May Park and Joseph de Grasse. The photography is exceptional for this period, even the use of a ghost image double exposure. It’s a three-reeler with the last reel missing, but fear not, none of Chaney’s performance is missing. Mirsalis does another excellent job in filling in the gaps and no one will be disappointed.I would recommend this package to anyone that has an interest in the history of cinematography. These films are important to the history of our nation. They show us what our grandparents would have seen in 1915. They also depict the birth of a star that has not gone out. It’s one that a Chaney fan should not be without.

Great for fans of the legendary Lon Chaney and of early silent movies in general. There's some deterioration, but the fact that these are part of the celebrated "Yukon Find" makes them all the more wonderful as links to history. There's some beautiful photography here and there, and at times when the image is crisp you get an impression of the gorgeous luminosity of orthochromatic nitrate film. Splendid musical accompaniment by Jon Mirsalis.

Jon Mirsalis did a great job with what material he was able to use. Besides some Nitrate damage which is to be expected with films of this age and rarity, any true Chaney fan will be delighted with this collection. Once again Jon also added original music of his own, which is very fitting, and works well with these films. Looking forward to more rare Chaney releases by him.

Chaney's early work is hard to find. ...very few titles still exist. This collection of footage from three of Chaney's early films is a rare find.We're lucky to have even fragments of these titles; I'm so glad they exist. I feel indebted to the people involved in preserving what we have leftof these features.

great stuff

Two thumbs up! These films are much like short stories. (I wish there were more of them.) All were directed by Joseph De Grasse and scripted by Ida May Park, his wife. Lon plays a dignified, older doctor (and his younger self) in “If My Country Should Call,” a bearded mountaineer in “A Mother’s Atonement,” and a lovestruck multiracial man in “The Place Beyond the Winds.” Overall, Lon’s fellow actors include Cleo Madison, Dorothy Phillips (twice), Jack Mulhall, Jay Belasco, and Joseph De Grasse.“A Mother’s Atonement” was easy to follow, despite a surprise-twist ending. The other two had just enough characters to keep me consulting the cast lists and replaying segments. There were really nice interiors in “If My Country Should Call” and beautiful scenic photography in the other two, including shimmering lakes and sunlight effects on an overhead shot. Artistically inset, “thought balloon” intertitles were occasionally used in “If My Country Should Call.”“A Mother’s Atonement” and “The Place Beyond the Winds” were among the frozen nitrate reels found in Dawson City, Yukon. All three films have some deterioration and missing reels. Chaney’s performances are completely intact in two of the films, but “A Mother’s Atonement” is missing a little. Dr. Jon C. Mirsalis has provided beautiful musical accompaniment and intertitles to explain the missing portions.