MIDI Foot Controller，MeloAudio Guitar Floor Multi-Effects Portable USB MIDI Foot Controller with 10 Foot Switches，2 Expression Pedal Jacks and 8 Host Presets

Best compact controller for the Kemper (and other guitar softwares). Way better size than the Kemper remote. This thing is super nice. Out of the box you power it on a hold down the correct button for the preset you want (button 3 for KPA) and it will remember that choice next time it's powered. Button clicks are responsive and changes are instantaneous. I never found the information online but here's the Kemper Defaults in Performance Mode: 1 - Tuner 2 - Stomp C 3 - Delay 4 - Performance x, Slot E A - Performance x, Slot A B - Performance x, Slot B C - Performance x, Slot C D - Performance x, Slot D UP/DOWN SWITCHES - select performance (will wait until you press desired slot) Now the one thing I didn't like was you cannot change any of these for the KMPA preset. If you want even a single button changed, you have to use the custom presets (but not a deal breaker). You open the custom menu by pressing down and powering on. You can modify the PC/CC# for switches, referencing your Amp's manual for necessary CC/PC commands. If you want button 4/E to operate as a preset, you have to tell it to select banks of 5. This thing comes with USB & Midi cables. It's about 11 x 4.5 x 1.5 in. I wasn't able to determine how much power it requires, but since it can operate on 2 AA batteries and be powered through USB 2, it should be less than 500mA. I'm powering it with an old phone brick rated for 700mA. If you're looking for an affordable, solid midi controller, this is it.

*Updated - I learned a few things over the last few weeks and I wanted to reflect that below* I had been looking for a while at this as a possible option as a midi controller for my HX Stomp. Currently among the HX Stomp community, the general consensus is the MC6 MKII is the gold standard, but it costs a significant chunk of change and probably does more than I’ll ever need. The DMC micro is the other really popular option, but I wasn't sure if the smaller two button arrangement would work well for the way my brain works. My primary interest was for a solid midi controller that could handle the Stomp's looper (I’m not a fan of one button) as well as some preset changes and additional Stomp control. I'm happy to say that over all it does this, though it does have some baffling limitations that I will outline in more detail below. Nevertheless, for the price it is a solid choice, and it can even control PC programs that are compatible with midi (such as HELIX Native) which is another big plus. Ultimately, if your primary goal with a Stomp, or other device, is preset changes and CC changes at a decent price, then this will work VERY well. For my current setup, I have a dual expression pedal connected to the Stomp to control volume/wah and the toe switch on it cycles through footswitch modes (something I wish the Midi Commander could do). I use the HX Stomp primarily in snapshot mode, and then the Midi Commander has two buttons for the looper, preset control, and two additional buttons that I attach to specific Stomp boxes or other parameter controls. It works VERY well, but once I came to understand what it COULD have been with some additional programming tweaks, I couldn’t help but feel a little disappointed. See below for more detail on some of the limitations that keep it from being 5 star: Caveats: PRESETS - The device will only do up to 36 preset changes for the HX Stomp (or any custom midi setting) UNLESS you set some of the 1 – 4 buttons as preset control, but even then it will max out at around 88. This is perhaps the most baffling and disappointing decision on the part of the designers. Many midi controllers with fewer switches can do well over that number. Since numerous high tech midi controlled devices can do well over 100 presets, and since the hardware can allow for it but the software can not, this remains a significant head scratcher. Initially I also couldn’t get my controller to let me use all eight buttons for CC control, but upon a reset a day later it seemed to work fine. I haven’t run into that bug since. CC Values - The device has FIXED CC values and will not allow you to input your own. The practical meaning of this is for devices like the HX Stomp, you won't be able to control snapshots or cycle through the footswitch modes (the biggest bummer for me). You can cycle through footswitch modes if you go into the HX Stomp and set the FS5 switch to do this, and then have the Midi Commander emulate the FS5, but that has other trade offs that make this solution a compromise at best. While this limitation is not as big of a letdown as the preset issue, it is also one of those features that a software update COULD allow it to do. It already has the most difficult aspect of all for a device to pull it off - the form factor. Giving it this option would open up a lot of possibilities! EXPRESSION PEDAL: The HX Stomp has a funky and somewhat annoying expression pedal design of its own, so I wasn't necessarily surprised that the expression pedal I bought for it wouldn't work on the Midi Commander, but it was still a bummer, and I've seen other posts on MeloAudio’s forum that indicate that other users have run into expression pedal problems. Melo Audio does support some obvious ones that you can find in their manual, and they design their own as well that should work, but it's still a bummer that you can run into issues here. I would REALLY like to have the Midi Commander take my expression pedal so that I can attach a dual foot switch to the HX Stomp to handle some of the controls the Midi Commander won't (like footswitch mode change - since Midi Commander can't send customized CC values). Still, it does have TWO ports for expression pedals, so when they do work, that is a nice amount of additional control. FIRMWARE UPDATES: The designers of the device have repeatedly hinted that they are planning updates to address the inability to send custom CC values, or to make more expression pedals function with the device, but nothing ever seems to happen here and there are no instructions on the device or the website of how to check for firmware updates. Again, the hard part about the Midi Commander is that it is VERY close to perfection, and if the device is capable of software updates like those described above (because it’s true, I didn’t build the thing and I don’t know if it really can, it just SEEMS plausible) it would only make the device SIGNIFICANTLY more of a contender in the midi control area. POWER PLUG/BATTERIES: It would be so nice if this had a standard 9 volt power plug port. As it stands, it has a USB power plug, which since most of the guitar gear world probably prefers to go the route of power supplies if not using batteries this was a bit of a miss to me. It does allow you to use rechargeable batteries, AND will even charge them for you in the device which is nice. Once charged, they last for many hours which is also a plus. I did get around the adaptor limitation buy buying a polarity reversing cable (to flip it from center positive to center negative since that’s what most pedal board power supplies are) and my particular power supply allows for low 4 – 5 volt options which seems to run this perfectly. Finally, a simple USB/to 5.55 mm cable adaptor took me the rest of the way home, but it was a bit more work and money than I would have preferred. The Nitpicky: The rubber feet on the bottom of this feel like they’re pretty much welded in there. I wanted to remove them to make it easier to attach them to my pedal board, but at the same time I wasn’t interested in creating any sort of gaping lumpy bottom to do this so I eventually backed off. It would be nice if they’d just had simple easy to remove – and reattach – rubber feet designs of many other pedals out there. There you have it. If, knowing the limitations of the device as outlined above, it still fits your needs, then my recommendation is to jump on board. It is still a powerful AND affordable device, but with a few quirky and perplexing weaknesses. I am happy I bought it, and particularly as an HX Stomp user, it has opened up more power and control on the Stomp than the base unit on its own is capable. Especially in regards to my main interest in using it (tapping into the looper) it excelled at better than I’d hoped.

I was searching for a compact midi controller that would work for the Avid Eleven Rack, which I use for live shows. Because of its small size, I decided to take a risk on this one and its matching expression pedal. While this controller doesn't come pre-programmed for the 11 rack, there are two easily accessible custom modes that are pretty intuitive to program--though to be honest the manual is thin and not well written. The lower four buttons can be set to PC, which lets me scroll through four rigs per bank (in order). I have the top four buttons are set to send CC, which I've assigned to my most used effects. The whole thing is not much bigger than three full size pedals and fits very nicely on my small pedal board. It appears to be well constructed and the screen is easy to read. I've had a chance to use it live in three shows now, and I'm very happy with it.

I have not been this frustrated buying something in a long time. While I will not claim to be an expert in MIDI routing and programming, I am certainly no novice and have been doing music production for over 15 years. I wanted a very simple solution for guitar effects while doing live shows for my Twitch channel. Using FL Studio I knew I would need to do some workaround, but I was not prepared for what lied ahead. All I needed was a pedal with functioning ON / OFF switches assigned throughout multiple banks. You do NOT get that with this product, in fact, you get something MUCH less. I'll elaborate. This controller is set up for six default "hosts" - AxeFX, JamUp, Kemper, ATOMIC Amps, BiasFX, and one more I don't remember. Essentially, if you use any of these VST's/hardware, you should be OK, as the pedal is optimized for those. HOWEVER, if you don't, then this is a very limited, essentially useless brick. The two extra "custom modes" bar you to assigning to only four CC channels - in other words, it can't toggle ON / OFF more than four parameters in your DAW. What about banks, you may ask? NONE. This thing doesn't even have multiple banks in the custom mode you can sift through, meaning whatever you assign your buttons to in your DAW, that's it. Absolutely ridiculous for a piece of hardware that should be capable of what just about any other MIDI controller can do. The closest thing I found with this product that I needed was "ALL CC MODE" which seemingly gives you different banks, but every CC only fires at 127 and does not toggle between 0 and 127 in this mode. In other words, when you press it, it will turn the parameter ON, but not OFF. Useless and inefficient for a guitar rig. For me to even discover that this wasn't a possibility, I had to spend hours researching YouTube and Google after not being able to figure this out on my own, using MeloAudio's own resources. This is because the manual is poorly translated English, filled with sentences that literally do not make sense. Their tech support is non-existent, and their forums are filled to the brim with unanswered questions about why this thing doesn't function intuitively. Lastly, I say this company is being purposefully misleading, as they list "JamUP; Bias Fx; Bias; Guitar Rig; MainStage; Ampkit; Revalver; AmpliTube; POD Farm; Mobile POD; Overloud TH; AXE FX3 ; Line6 HX TOMP and so on" under the title "Commonly used effect software." This, of course, leads the buyer to believe that this pedal should be compatible with all of these programs. This is explicitly NOT the case, as I use Guitar Rig, and Guitar Rig does not have any built-in functionality with third party controllers like this (and yes, I tried it anyway just to be sure with no luck). Additionally, their descriptions are vague about a lot of the features, which should have been a red flag for me to begin with. In summary, if you have one of the six hosts this is programmed for, you will probably like this product. If you don't, and need it for a purpose like I described, keep your sanity (and your money) and do not buy this. You will find yourself either extremely limited or unable to accomplish what you set out to do. One pro: it's physical build is rather nice.

I bought the MeloAudio midi commander to use with my Positive Grid bias head. My initial intention was to be able to switch between the various presets available in the bias head. The midi commander does this flawlessly! I watched several youtube demos of this unit before I decided to buy it and they were all very positive. “Really”. If you use guitar processors such as axe fx, kemper, positive grid, etc this little hi quality unit is well worth checking out as it is already preprogrammed for those units! It also syncs very well with jamup, bias fx and others. And of course you can cc and pc midi information and customize your midi software setup! It’s compact very cool looking and runs off 2 AA batteries!

Pros: light, sturdy-ish enough-ish (def not tank built), OLED screen, many stomps, 2 expression pedal inputs. Cons: I hear support is terrible to nonexistent, and likewise, engineering/design missed the boat on a lot of things, the big ones: - the switches are not momentary (they only send a message per step, not for both down and up, the latter would be way more useful, e.g. "do something if the stomp is held for 2 seconds") - there is no "pure midi message mode" / full flexibility (e.g. the arrow stomps always send PC messages and alter the other stomp + light states, would be nice to just if they could be set to just emit midi messages / work like the others, so we have full 10-stomps to make use of / control. They *do* however send an incrementing and decrementing Program Change counter number, so I've hacked my scripts to infer which button was pressed and gone from there. It's working, but unideal [see next]) - the light programming is just.plain.wrong. sigh. If you toggle up / down with arrow stomps, the lights reset, and don't reflect true state. e.g. stomp one, it lights up, stomp arrow, now that light turns off, despite the fact that next step on that stomp will send the CC 0 and light remains off. Just all kinds of wrong. And again, give us the flexibility to set basic, independent behavior. That boat was slow, just floating by, little to no wake, its passengers were starboard sipping cocktails and waving, and this boat was also: missed. - there's a beautiful little OLED screen, let us send messages / text to it FFS!!!! - same goes for lighting, all the non-China-churned-out-rush-builds midi controllers out there with lights, if you send messages back to them, you can control them

I needed a midi controller for my Macbook Air to run the Prime application from Loop Community. I am using it to send midi command changes for next song, previous song, chorus and verses, and it works great. was initially worried about the price and had quality concerns, it seems to be well made and offers power by USB or it can be powered with batteries as well. Very pleased with this purchase.

I should have listened to another reviewer on here. It won't work with Ableton Live's Looper. Looper will function with MIDI Note or CC functionality, but the MIDI Commander sends a constant CC signal, which Looper interprets as "holding the button", this results in undesirable functions, like pressing Stop actually Clears the loop 2 seconds later. I loved the product other than it doesn't work for my needs. It's well-built, easy to program, relatively inexpensive. If they added MIDI Note functionality, I'd buy it again.