BY MERZY The First Pen Liquid Eye Liner | Waterproof Eyeliner, Long Lasting, Smudge-Resistant, High-Intensity Color | (P2, Dark Brown, Brownie)

This is a dupe of the Kat Von D Tattoo liner, but it's actually even better! Swatched both on my hand and rubbed running water on it and this stayed on better than KVD. I'm surprised there's only 4 reviews, bc this liner is awesome. It also has a brush tip, not felt tip, which I think makes application easier, and the tip will last longer.

I bought this eyeliner because it said that it doesnt smudge and lasts all day, but even if you dont sweat or your face gets oily, this eyeliner can get all over your eyes. The color is very pretty. As long as you dont wear this to a party or sweat a lot, you will be fine with this eyeliner.

I mostly only buy mid-high end makeup products, but I wanted to try this eyeliner. It's certainly on par with Kat Von D's tattoo liner, actually I think it's significantly better -- the Kat Von D doesn't have as long staying power. This one is easy to apply and stays on until I wash it off at night, and comes off pretty easily as well. What more could you ask for from a felt tip liner? Brilliant!

I really like that you can draw a thin line if you want it. I gave this a 4 because it will rub off if you don't let it dry well. I found out that if you put eyeshadow on first and then put the liner on it stays on better. But it takes awhile for this liner to dry and not get on your eyelid where you don't want it.I do like the look and I like that it's a true brown which is hard to find. I'm a redhead and prefer brown eyeliner and mascara and this is one of the only liners I've found that looks brown.

I got 2. One for my daughter and one for me. It doesn't do anything... as if it was used or something. Hardly any color coming out. Same thing for my daughter's. Very disappointing 😞

This product is amazing! I work in a kitchen that regularly reaches 95+ degrees, and I have been searching everywhere for a product that can stand up to the heat. My search is over. This picture is after a sweltering 10 hour work day, sweat was literally pouring down my face and this eyeliner didn't budge! I am beyond impressed and would recommend this to anyone looking for a smudge free eyeliner that can really hold its own in a sweaty oily environment.

I really love this eyeliner. It is a brush tip and in brown which is extremely hard to find (for me anyways). I highly recommend this eyeliner. And the price is great. I have been looking for a replacement for Kat Von D. I have been having issues with the last couple KVD eyeliners I have purchased. This one is great. It lasts all day. I love how it applies. It is easy for me to do a sharp wing. Highly recommend!

This stuff is really not great. The color isn't very saturated and it wears off quickly like others do. Stila' All Day liner is better and it's not even that great with wear. It does. At least have the color saturation that most are looking for.