essenceBye Bye Panda Eyes essence Smudge-Proof Volumising and Defining Mascara, Smudge-proof Formula, No. 01 Black, Defining, Natural, Vegan, Perfume-free, 16 mlClimatePartner certified

Ordered this after a review saying this was a tubing mascara. Which is what I'm looking for. This was perfect. Short bristles that don't reach my eyelid, just the lashes. No clumping. I will need to curl my lashes first next time. There was no smudging!! Very often I forget I've just put mascara on, close my eyes and end up with a black smudge under my eyes. I was feeling confident, so I covered my bottom lashes, too. Then, the ultimate test - to go out on a hot day and see if it stayed in place. Yes it did. My ultra sensitive eyes weren't affected, either. In the evening, I gently washed it off with warm water on a facecloth. In future, I will pre-curl my lashes to get them more noticeable. There is no major volume with this mascara, but is perfect for not irritating sensitive eyes, or washing off in a menopausal hot flush. I'm very happy.

Mascara is smudge proof but doesn't lengthen , just colours but smudge proof was the reason I bought it so not disappointed.

I love this mascara sm, I get almost daily compliments on my lashes since using this, it’s lovely, though can be clumpy if you don’t apply it properly, don’t wiggle the applicator at the base of your lashes, and gently make sure to get the tips of your lashes for full length potential, generally cry proof, but not always, do one coat, then cover your lashes in powder, then do a second coat and curl so it doesn’t smudge because ngl it’s not summer proof without powder. I’m the girl in the coat, that’s my lashes after using it

I thought I’d try it because I’d seen good write ups however I am a little disappointed. It most definitely left me with panda eyes after only a few hours. It’s a nice creamy formula and ok for the price point but I won’t be purchasing again.

Best mascara had for a long time.Doesn't smudge.Separrts eyelashes no clumps .For the price ...Well better than alot I've bought for double the price .

Very good quality for a good price

Is quite lengthening but does not hold a curl. It is also not buildable as the 4th coat looked the same as the 1st when I tried. If you like dramatic mascara this is not for you

I've got super fat eyelids so anything on my eyes turns in to a splodgey mess within an hour.Other claim to be waterproof, yes. But tubby eyelid proof? No.Found this. What a result. Tiniest bit of smudging by the end of the day, but that is a huge win for me! They don't give the biggest lashes, so that's a little sucky. But it's a price I'm willing to pay.Hard to find these elsewhere. Wondering if they've stopped making them? I shall stock up!