eXtremeRate ThumbsGear Interchangeable Ergonomic Thumbstick for PS5 Controller, for PS4 All Model Controller - 3 Height Domed and Concave Grips Adjustable Joystick - Black

Fits great on my Dualshock 4 controller. I have ExtremeRates Decade Tournament Controller Kit on mine and it still fits perfectly. Love how easy it is to put on and swap out, but isnt easy enough for the joystick to just fall out. Installation is simple enough, you just have to sepereate the front and back shell of the controller and lift up on the piece holding the motherboard and all the triggers. Tried to put it on my SCUF Envision controller, but did not fit and made a scratchy noise when i tried moving the stick. This however is expected, as its only for Playstation controllers. Great product, i have a total of 2 of these sets now (One in metallic red, the other in black.) and they both work great. After some use they DO get some slight wear lines on the lower part of the removable joystick, however this doesnt effect the use at all. Have had mine for around 1 year, and only use 2 of the sticks. Great value and great purchase if you want to up youre accuracy in shooter games.

These analog sticks allow you to be so much more precise with aiming on FPS games like call of duty and battlefield . They allow you to be much more competitive. I have a combination of mid height on the left and longest stick on the right for aiming. Extreme rates products are amazing and I’ve found that a fully built extreme rate controller is better than a dual sense edge controller in almost every way.

Really like these except for they come off fairly easy so wouldn't recommend for competitive gamers

The thumb placement is fire 🫡💥Grip pretty sturdyEasy install id say better than any brand Control Freeks

Works beautifully, would buy another one for my girlfriends controller and other colors for my own controller.

Fits the PS5 controller perfectly, I mainly use these for FPS games. The grip is perfect and the installation was very easy.

Normally I love stuff from EXTREMERATE. Most of their products are well designed, fit together great and work perfectly. The sticks are by far the worst things I've purchased from them. They're super tight and you have to apply a ton of pressure to slide the caps onto your stick. Once they are on, you feel like you were going to break the board or the joystick trying to pull them off. Odds are, you are going to have to pull them off because of a massive design flaw. The lower part that fits over the joystick is too small. You can see the edges of it when you move the stick all the way in one direction. It wouldn't be a huge thing, but the edges snag the friction ring and prevent the stick from returning to it's original position. They could have fixed this issue by having that part go down as far as it does on the original joysticks, so I'm not really sure why they went this route.

Could be user error when installing but, the joysticks rub against the controller casing causing it to stick and not flick back to center. Adjustable knobs come in 2 different sizes and has 2 different shapes. Grand total of 6 swappable knobs. Great idea, not so good execution.