RimmelExaggerate Eye Definer, Blackest Black, 1 Count, Waterproof Long Lasting Easy Twist Up Self-S Exaggerate Auto Waterproof Eye Definer, Earl Grey, 0.01 Fluid Ounce, 1 Count

I wanted to try a brown liner and this had better reviews than my go-to felt liner, the Nyx Epic Ink liquid liner. Pleasantly surprised to find it holding up better than any other liner I’ve tried. Granted, I did apply a little primer to my lash line before applying, but it lasted 13 hours with minimal smudging, on a heavy fog/mist day too. As someone with oily eyelids, this is truly a feat. The only thing that would make this better is a more precise tip (like a felt liner achieves), but for the price the quality is unmatched.

This is great, great eyeliner for we ‘old folks’ who prefer to ‘draw’ our eyeliner on with pencils/thin crayons rather than wee brushes. This is the BEST eyeliner of this type that I’ve found! It does not smear and lasts all day- except for the corners of my eye (I still have yet to find any product to avoid this- my eyes just tend to tear up in the corner). But if I keep up and just wipe the wee corner of my eye- the rest of the eyeliner stays on for HOURS! Also, it’s not ‘waterproof’ (the products that are can be great, and better for super longevity but are VERY difficult to remove at the end of the day). So, I prefer this, for my every workday eyeliner! I like the dark brown since I’m fair haired. 😊

I am really bad at make up. This eyeliner is the best I’ve ever used and I am 52. I do it on the water line of my eyes and I can’t believe how simple it is. Usually my eyeliner is always a hot mess. This defines my eyes and it’s so fast put on. I am definitely buy more. I bought the brown and it’s so nice.

Totally not water proof but it does stay on very well. Been looking for a eyeliner that could handle my long days and not make me look like a clown by the end of it. These are it! Long lasting and no smearing. These didn't make my eyes strong either like a lot of the makeup these days. Highly recommended

I keep several/colors in my kit!!! Long wearing water resistant formula that is crazy inexpensive. Works as well as my Stila at a fraction of the price.

I've been using this eyeliner for years, and my local CVS stopped carrying it. Such a tragedy. Now I have to buy it online. I've tried a lot of different eyeliners, and nothing compares to this one. So good.

I'm forever searching for the best eyeliner. I've tried super expensive ones but they are not good. This works as well as a $50 eyeliner. It stays put for the most part.

This is my all time favorite/ go to eyeliner. The design allows for easy application, straight lines and lasts all day into evening. It is also easy to do a touch up when needed. For the quality and ease of use- the price is great!!

The media could not be loaded.  This brown eyeliner is very opaque. The formula has a nice creamy, smoothness to it, and it glides easily over the eyelids and on the waterline. It has a high pigmented matte finish that is long wearing, even on the waterline. After it is properly set, it will not smudge easily compared to my other liners. I love the richness of the color and the fact that it is retractable. This liner shade isn't as harsh as a black liner, so it makes it perfectly suitable to wear during the daytime. I've been wearing this on a daily basis for over a month now and I'm hooked. Great purchase. Would recommend.If my review was helpful let me know by clicking on the ''Helpful'' button :) 👍🏻

Love this eyeliner! Easy to use and long lasting, only disappointment is that the price has shot up, however worth every penny!It’s a fab shade of dark brown, a more subtle day look! Will be buying it in black for nights out for a more dramatic look

I love this product and the smudger at one end is so useful. My eyes look the samecat bedtime when I remove it as it did in the morning when I apply i5

The pencil inside just kept snapping off everything I used it so I'm wondering if it's actually ligit?????

This is my favourite eyeliner because it stays put and is long lasting but easy enough to remove.