ETUDECurl Fix Mascara & Eyelash Curler SET #1 Black New | A curl fix mascara that keeps fine eyelashes powerfully curled up for 24 hours by ETUDE's own Curl 24H Technology | K-beauty

This mascara is great! It holds a curl perfectly, and I love the brown color. No bleeding or smudging. It is difficult to get off, but that's usually the case with waterproof mascaras. I'll definitely be repurchasing.

The mascara is OK. It has a very skinny wand and definitely stays on. It doesn’t add any volume, but it will keep your lashes raised. So if you use a lash curler, it is more likely to keep your eyelashes in that position than other mascaras. However, it is pretty hard to remove so you definitely need an oil or an oil-based mascara remover. Because of that, if you are messy when applying, it is pretty hard to clean, including when the mascara is still wet. I have heard that some waterproof mascaras contain Teflon so I’m really hoping that this one doesn’t, because I did not know about its staying power and I can’t return it once I opened the package

It’s pretty good for color and neatness. But not for fullness at all. It does make your lashes separate nicely and holds a curl well. but if you prefer a more voluminous eyelash look. Not for you. Also hard to wash off. I have to use an oil cleanser every night to wash off. But it’s a good mascara if you need it long lasting

This mascara will curl your lashes AND keep them that way until you take it off! If your lashes don’t usually hold a curl, you need this stuff.As far as being hard to remove… yes, it’s harder to remove than other mascaras. It did not budge at all when I used micellar water, but came off without any issues when I used an oil cleanser (I used Beauty of Joseon ginseng cleansing oil). I placed a little oil on a cotton round, held it over each eye for just about 20 seconds or so, and that worked great!

This is definitely a "wet" formula, which I didn't mind, though I find those tend to clump easier for me. I was excited for the curl capability but saw very little. Upon trying to remove it later in the day, it seems to have dried my lashes to the point of feeling like stiff concrete. I used eye makeup removal oil as well as soap and water and neither seemed to work to remove most of it. I had to rub at my eyelashes vigorously to get most of it off and still some was left. It turned from hard concrete to a sticky, gummy consistency that just would not remove. I can't see myself using this again in the future since it is TOO waterproof, to the point that even makeup remover couldn't get it off when I needed it off. The force needed to remove it would undoubtedly harm my eyelashes if I used it all the time with them hardening and then being rubbed to remove it so hard all the time, so for my eyelash's health, I won't be using this again. Shame since it looks so cute. I don't know why it's such a difficult formula.

it makes my eyelashes long, like they almost touch my eyebrows, and the curl truly lasts all day like nothing changes. it doesn’t make my lashes go down. i guess my only problem is that it dries out my eyes and feels a bit heavy. it looks nice but it just doesn’t feel that nice and it is a little hard to take off. however, it’s easier to take it off by using the brand’s lip and eye remover.

I have oily skin and finding a mascara that doesn’t end up under my eye in a couple hours has been a challenge. So far, this one has only very slightly been under my eye 1/10 times of wearing it, and because I got brown, it’s a lot less noticeable than black mascara.It has great staying powder, to the extent I’m having to buy a new makeup remover because micellar water and Vaseline are not doing it for this! So even after not being able to fully remove it at night after wearing it most of the day, there’s still barely any under my eyes when I wake up! (I am planning to get a better makeup remover, don’t worry)I curl my lashes and then apply this and it holds the shape really well. I’ve tried others that lose the curled shape over time, but that hasn’t happened with this one. You also don’t need to apply much for it to look great. Not much clumping, good separation of the lashes for the most part!

Beautiful texture and color. BUT it’s incredibly difficult to remove, AND I noticed it’s making my eyelashes fall out and will continue to fall out for a couple of days after use despite not having this or any other product applied (for those who might speculate this is from rubbing too hard or pulling on them to remove the product- No. my eyelashes will fall out during the day and I will find them on my cheeks or in my eye with product still on them) it does hold amazingly just unfortunately the side effect is too much :(