Dr. Scholl'sDr. Scholl's Ultrasoft Leather Insoles for Dress Shoes (Men's 8-14) // All-Day Comfort with Massaging Gel plus a Real Leather Surface

Foot pain wasn't my problem. I put a pair of these in work boots, and the insoles are soft and give good support. The leather should last a long time.

Great cover. It served its purpose

Great support and confort! I bought these specifically because my shoes fit me a little loose and the inserts provide the right amount of support and fill so that my fit is just right.

I find these help, but they didn't work out in the shoes that I had wanted them for. They made the shoes feel too tight on the upper part of my foot. Those shoes were already borderline in that way through (up and down from the top of my foot to the bottom.) So the thickness of the inserts put me over the edge. Also, in those shoes, I could really feel the edge of these on the underside of my arch.I switched them to my Izod sneakers which are flat casuals, not really any extra padding at all, and they felt much better. In those shoes, I don't ever notice the 'cut off.' I think the difference really was just in size up and down on the shoe.They really only pad the heal, but they do it with a gel that's firm but giving, not too squishy. The outside of these has the look and feel of leather so they would be perfect and look nice in dress shoes.

These move around in your shoe so much that they end up hurting after 5 minutes. Walking barefoot on concrete feels better than these garbage insoles. I am throwing these in the trash where they belong.