Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner 0.5 ml

Brilliant product stays all day

This gives a medium line or finer line if using gently. Alternatively thicker lines if pressure is applied alongside. It is of a good texture, very easy to apply, tidy and of both a partial matt and glossed appearance. Stays on well and doesn't move. Is really easy to remove when required and if left on overnight through tiredness or forgetfulness, it doesn't look too shabby at all the next day, bedding is eyeliner free too. The cap is easy to remove when needed and fits snugly when not. A nice quantity of product supplied and the colour is bold but not bright making it ideal for day and night. A striking look can still be achieved with a little pressure thus giving thicker strokes and a bolder look. For comparison in appearance a fresh tattoo is relatively of the same hue without pressure being applied. This eyeliner saves much time and mess!

Truth be told, this is a really nice eyeliner. It's very black and it's very opaque, so there's little building to do when you apply it. The tip is nice, thin, but shorter- not something I personally like but it still works well when you're trying to get that nice cat eye. The packaging is a little weird, seems like the cap is springloaded or something, but it stays on securely and doesn't come off in my bag.The formula itself is very watery, and when you're applying it to the back of you hand it does bleed and feather a little, which got me kinda worried; thankfully, this doesn't happen on the eye, and the watery consistency actually helps you get super close to the lashline and inbetween those little bits of eyelid between your lashes. I've not got sensitive eyes but I feel like this made my eyes water ever so slightly, so that might be something to keep in mind. It's one of those eyeliner formulas that dries quite glossy and "heavy", sitting on the eyelid as if it's going to crack and flake later on in the day, but it actually never does; that being said, it does tend to disappear right on the very inner corner, where your eyelid tends to be in contact with your eyeball. Not a problem for me because I don't generally like that part but it definitely comes off there. Doesn't smudge, doesn't transfer, waterproof to an extent (dab the water away, rubbing will wipe it right off) and doesn't bleed when I cry with it on. Little bit of a hassle to remove, but use some oil and you're good to go.All in all it's a real good quality eyeliner, but I definitely think you can find comparable felt liners for a whole lot less. L'oreal Super Slim in brown is my usual go to and it works just as well, granted you set it with a powder. Still a nice indulgence if you feel like spoiling yourself.

I am a daily user of liquid eyeliner and spent a long time finding one that didn't irritate my eyes (I have dry eyes and blepharitis). I tried natural versions, but in the end it just didn't cut it. I decided instead to go for one with longevity, and after searching online I found this eyeliner which was recommended for not budging.So I used to have issues with tearing in the corners of my eyes due to eyeliner. I thought I was going to have to stop wearing it. I tried pencils, organic types, and oil types too but to no avail. This eyeliner however does not irritate my eyes at all, and it stays in place all day. It even survived spa days, it's that good (I'm very self conscious without make up!).It's a beautiful solid deep black hue, and is easy to apply. I have found the last one I bought particularly "wet" so harder to get precision, but usually the tip is very easy to create fine flicks and lines. Either way, I'd recommend this eyeliner completely for daily use. I also have no issues getting it off with an oil based makeup remover that is kind to eyes.Uodate: I just bought the alloy one and initially didn't like it as it's very light on the lid. But it's really nice as a less intense look and also stays on all day. It's actually very pretty but you can't really wear it with eyeshadow as you can't see it.

I don’t understand how this eyeliner has such great reviews. They come off or smudge under my eyes after an hour. Cheaper brand eye liners stay longer than this. I’ve had the cat eye look for a long time now and went through tons of waterproof eyeliners but these might be the worst ones.

Smudge proof as long as it stays completely dry, unfortunately it will definitely smudge when wet. Picture shows this eyeliner (top) with my cheap £5 eyeliner (bottom) I'll keep this one for 'special' occasions as the brush is quite nice and I'll try a primer, but sadly its not worth the cost.

I am so impressed with this eyeliner. Easy to apply, stays on all day no matter what yet easy to remove without any special products. The colour is amazing especially if you are cool toned and fair as it’s not as harsh as black yet dark enough. Been using Stila for years

Love this eyeliner. Stays on all day and easy to apply.