L'Oreal Paris Makeup Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black, 0.05 fl; oz.

Let me start by saying how AMAZING Amazon is! I ordered this item yesterday at 12PM yesterday. Within 22 hours, it is on my doorstep! I made use of the free prime offer I have (student perks!). About the liner - I bought the intense black. It looks like it's still wet even after it has dried - that is what gives it the intense color and non-matte, non-pencil liner finish. The applicator is easy to use and the felt tip is not very flexible which make it easy to apply from any angle. Seems to wash off with water and some rubbing but stays put otherwise. My only gripe is the amount of liquid is very less, that is, the size of the vial that holds the liner is small. I guess liner should be thrown out after a few months, thats why. Thanks Amazon, and thanks L'oreal!!! Update 01/27- This thing flakes off without your trace. If that's what you want (an eyeliner that does not have staying power) then buy this!

Love this eyeliner, quality is same as the expensive Lancôme one I was using previously. In fact I’d say it’s identical and I’m very glad I tried it, I’m now saving LOTS of $. Highly recommend. i have already ordered again, it’s my new go to liner! No complaints whatsoever!

My favorite thing! Always have it everywhere. I'm not a big fan of all L'oreal's produce, but this one is the best. I tried more than a hundred of them, because I love thin lines. I have used liquid eyeliners for over 10 years, and decided to chose this one, because: 1) I love a felt-tip applicator, it's very easily to apply and to create any type of lines: thin or bold. 2) I love the consistence: it looks wet and bright on the eyes. 3) I use color 'carbon black', it looks glossy and rich. 4) It removes easily with any eye makeup remover or just water&soap. What I don't like about this liner: 1) It works perfect for 2-3 hours. It works good for 3-6 hours. You should apply it again after 6 or more hours. 2) The small size. I buy it every 2-3 months (comparing with another liners, which works for 4-6 months) 3) It doesn't look perfectly rich and bright on your eyes for the first or third use. Nevertheless, I love it!

I’ve been wearing this eyeliner for years now and it became harder and harder to find. I fear it is on the road to being discontinued. Luckily I was able to find it here so I bought around ten! They all were perfect and fresh. No clumps, no dried up messes. Just my trusty eyeliner!

So L’Oreal stopped making this particular liquid liner, which is unfortunate because it’s AMAZING and the only one I’ve used for years.

This was my favorite liquid liner for YEARS. Great eyeliner for those starting out with liquid. The handle was easy to hold, felt tip was precise but easy to maneuver., black had great pigmentation. I'd tried more expensive brands, but always came back. In the past few years however, the quality on this eyeliner has been hit or miss. Some were as great as I'd remembered, but some would dry out fast, have poor pigmentation, or a floppy felt tip. I never understood how there were bad reviews on this eyeliner and I always bought in bulk whenever it went on sale, but I'm disappointed to say it's time to move on and re-try other brands.

I have used this for years and it is now hard to find. Thanks Amazon

I love this brand and make of eyeliner and have used for years, like over 10 years to make my winged eye or just a finished casual look. My only complaint about this shipment is the liner liquid leaked out and I called for refund to replace the manufacturer issue. The liner is darkest black, lasts for hours, doesn’t peel (if not old product) can layer easily, simple to use, dries quickly. I love this liner!