L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Super Slim Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra-Fine Felt Tip, Quick Drying Formula, Glides on Smoothly, Black, Pack of 1

I have used this for years and I have tried many other brands including top brands and I still LOVE this one the best! It says it lasts 16 hours and I feel it could last even longer! It is smudge proof as long as you don’t touch your eyes or cry! It’s not waterproof, which is personally my favorite thing because I hate waterproof anything on my face. I like to wipe my makeup off within seconds not scrubbing my face forever! I get compliments on my makeup every time I wear it and everyone always asks me what I use and I share this with them. It glides on so easily and draws just like a nice 🖊️ pen!**The only problem I’ve ever had is that every once in awhile I’ll get one that’s dried out because when you try to put it on it barely comes out and you can tell because the top is stiff. Just contact them and get a replacement! Their customer service is fantastic!Anyway, hope this helps someone ☺️

This eyeliner works great! It makes a very thin line but it's very dark. I have a hard time removing it at night but it does last all day without smudging

I have been using this product for a few years now, it definitely is not smudge or waterproof, but that is perfect for me. If you are someone who is learning to use eyeliner or just doesn’t have the steady hands to get the shape you want on your first try, an eyeliner that is easy to remove is perfect! If you do not rub your eyes or submerge your face in water the eyeliner should last all day. I love the shape of the tip of this eyeliner, it gives me a lot of control and was the easiest for me to use as a beginner. The eyeliner does start to fade and dry out after 3-4 months for me, though it depends on my use. If I use it on top of eyeshadow it dries faster than if I use it on its own. Overall it’s a good product for the price and is great for beginners & those who aren’t too cosmetic savvy!

Was looking for a cheap and quick eyeliner and this ended up being more than! So easy to apply on the eyelid goes on smooth, the shade is vibrant and stays on long and most importantly does not smudge.

This creates the thinnest smoothest line. Great product. I have tried to use the pencils but they do not stay in place and bleed away. Not this one. I want every color.

good but doesn't last more than a month of daily use.

Based on my purchase history, I used to purchase 1 of these every 3 months. It's now drying out so quickly, I am having to order 1 every 3 weeks. Changing brands and never coming back.

I am in my 60s so fairly experienced with putting on eyeliner. I liked the applicator on this product because I could draw on a very thin line. As a woman of a certain age, I want an understated look. I thought I had hit the jackpot when I first looked in the mirror after putting this eyeliner on. I had managed a thin line that complemented my eyes. I was very pleased and got myself together to leave for the store. Thanks heavens I looked in the hallway mirror before I went out the door because my eyes were definitely not understated at that point. In just a little while I had gone from looking nice to looking like I was going to either a Halloween party or a Goth festival. The liner had faded around my lash line but spread to my upper lids and under my eyes. I don't have oily lids and I had put on a primer with a light tan eyeshadow. I have never had a liner run this bad, especially in the time it took for me to go from upstairs to downstairs, feed the dog, and put on my coat. I know most of the reviews on this product are positive but my experience definitely wasn't. I don't know why, I just know that this was the worst eyeliner experience I have had since I started wearing makeup in my teens. I did try using it again but had pretty much the same experience so tossed it. I now use Physician's Formula Eye Booster 2 in 1. It has a perfectly controllable and thin brush that allows me to get close to my eyelids and it lasts the entire day.