Northshire Farms 5 lbs. Naturally Grown Seed Non GMO Red Pontiacs and German Butterballs

I will say that these potatoes simply came in a box from the postal service. No directions - so if you're new to potatoes and require some instructions, these probably are not for you. However, if you know what you're doing and do need a "how to" card... they are fantastic. I planted and they have grown like crazy. I cannot wait until I'm ready to find out what's beneath the ground.

These are NOT potato ‘slips’. They are certainly not anywhere near ready to plant within days, as those I have received from other suppliers in the past have been. Not one of them has an eye on it, so I wouldn’t even know where to start cutting each into smaller pieces for planting. So basically what you sent me was a 5 pound bag of very expensive full-size potatoes (1st photo). Two of these are so big (4.5”+) that they weigh almost a pound each. I also included your featured photo (2nd photo), in which small potatoes WITH EYES are shown, & a photo similar to the type of potato that is “ready for planting” that I have received in the past (last photo). I live in AZ (zone 9), so the window for planting potatoes is very short. By the time your potatoes sit, develop eyes, & sprout (instead of arriving sprouted & ready to go), get cut into pieces with one or two eyes, heal, and are planted, my window for planting will be long gone. VERY DISAPPOINTING.

These shipped to us very well and we just planted them for the season. My mother bought the same potato mix last year and the yield was wonderful. The potatoes taste great! Fresh is MUCH better than store bought.

When I received these they were huge and didn't have 1 sprout on them, but I thought ok I can sprout them, well they didn't sprout not one of them. I ended up throwing them away these were a total waste of money!!

The quality was not up to my expectations. Some of the potatoes (the white ones) were already about to decay when I received them. I had taken a photo but decided to just leave the issue alone so, I recently deleted it.

The potatoes were not like the fist bag I bought. I do not know if I bought the first bag off this seller or elsewhere. But I was disappointed in this second bag because they got like diseased or something. I had to throw them away. I gave it two stars because I don't know if it was something I did wrong on my part. I didn't have this problem with the first bag I bought and I didn't do anything different that I know off, they are growing beautifully.

They don't answer emails - missed two deliver by dates - finally received good quality seed potatoes.I will buy from them again.

Lots of healthy-looking plants have come up in my zone 7 garden (24 plants so far and seeing new ones every few days). Hopefully it won't get blazingly hot here for at least another two months. I will update on how they progress and ultimately how they taste.